
This review is the result of quite a few recommendations to try a central florida franchise that goes by the name
Broadway Ristorante & Pizzeria, or more commonly known as "Broadway Pizza." We visited the one located on alafaya trail, just across the street from the University of Central Florida. We were particularly interested in this place because of what we had heard about their "buffalo calamari", dipped in buffalo hot sauce and served with blue cheese. Even though our main goal with this blog is to seek and find Orlando's best calamari in it's purest form, it's nice to try a new or different take on an old classic now and then.
We sat ourselves and scanned the appetizer menu to quickly find that we had a dilemma on our hands. Broadway offered the buffalo calamari as well as a traditional version, so once again in the name of science we did the logical thing and ordered both! So here's our Tuesday 2-fer, even though it's actually Thursday. ;P
The Traditional - $7.25

The traditional calamari came out and was presented very well. A nice round white plate with sprinkles of Oregano and Parmesan cheese and the calamari laid out on a bed of fresh lettuce. A customary steaming cup of marinara perched in the center and of course the lemon slices waiting to be drizzled. There was definitely enough to satisfy two people, so for $7.25, Broadway is definitely giving you your moneys worth. Now came the most important part, the taste. The calamari itself was very good, cooked well, not chewy or rubbery in fact very tender. As good as this review sounds so far, there was a problem, and I'll get back to what the problem was in just a minute...
Buffalo Spice - $7.75

Now for the buffalo spice calamari that we had heard so much about. It too came out presented very well with the big white plate, the bed of lettuce, and sprinkles of what looked like paprika or ground red pepper. The calamari was noticeably seasoned with a glimmering red sheen on it very similar to what you would see on a fresh order of hot wings. A cup of bleu cheese accompanied our squid along with the lemon slices on the side. After taking a few bites, it was easy to see how this could be such a fan favorite and how the additional .50 cents gets easily justified.
The calamari was tender, not rubbery just like it's traditional counterpart, and the buffalo flavoring was excellent. It truly was a very nice departure from the normal stuff, however it too suffered from the same "problem" that I will now get into since it applied to both orders.
I'm going to take a stab here and guess that Broadway Pizza (University) only has one deep fryer in the kitchen. Why would I make such a guess? Because both orders of calamari were soggy, there was absolutely no crunch to them at all. What does this have to do with having only a single fryer you may ask?
Well soggy calamari is the result of oil temperature rapidly dropping from too much calamari (or any other frozen food) being added to the deep fryer at one time. Most calamari in restaurants is kept frozen or refrigerated of course to keep it fresh and to extend it's shelf life. The chef may have decided to drop both orders in the same fryer so they'd be ready at the same time which is understandable, but it really did a disservice to both orders.
For many of you that have had Broadway's calamari and are thinking, "mine is never soggy, what is this dummy talking about?" I understand your viewpoint, but remember you probably only ordered one plate and it's unlikely that someone else in the place ordered the calamari at the exact same time, so the oil probably maintained the right temperature.
All in all, we really liked Broadway's take on calamari and would definitely go back again. The sogginess was a downer but the buffalo spice version definitely gets points for originality. We will add it to our list of favorites and as always keep the suggestions coming and as always, happy dining!